The Redwoods of Coast and Sierra
NPS Arrowhead logo

COMPARISON OF COAST REDWOOD AND SIERRA REDWOOD

IN MANY RESPECTS the Coast Redwood and the Sierra Redwood are similar, and in others they are dissimilar. In the following brief tabular summary are indicated some of the similarities and some of the differences that are to be noted.

SIMILARITIES IN THE COAST REDWOOD (SEQUOIA SEMPERVIRENS) AND THE SIERRA REDWOOD (SEQUOIA GIGANTEA)

NAME: Sequoia; Redwood; Big Trees.

COMMON CHARACTERISTICS: Evergreen; cone-bearing. Reddish bark and reddish heartwood. Absence of resin cells and resin. Abundance of tannin, a protective chemical.

DISTRIBUTION: Native only in western North America. Cultivated successfully as ornamentals.

CONSERVATION: The United States Government, the State of California, the Save-the-Redwoods League, and various other organizations have done much to preserve the Redwood forests.

DIFFERENCES IN THE COAST REDWOOD AND THE SIERRA REDWOOD

Sequoia sempervirens Sequoia gigantea
DISCOVERY (leading to botanical description):
By Vancouver expedition, in Santa Cruz County, California, 1792 By Walker party, in Mariposa County, California, 1833

NAME:
Called "Palo Colorado" or Red Tree by Spanish-Americans Called "Wawona" or Big Tree by native Indians

COMMON NAMES:
Sequoia; California Redwood; Coast Redwood; Redwood Sequoia; Mammoth Tree; Giant Sequoia; Sierra Redwood; Big Tree

SPECIES NAME:
sempervirens—always living gigantea—giant

NAME USED IN THIS BOOK:
Coast Redwood Sierra Redwood

DISTRIBUTION:
California and southern Oregon In California only
Summer fog-belt area along Pacific Coast Western slope of Sierra Nevada
500-mile range, Santa Lucia Mountains to southern Oregon 250-mile range from Tulare County to Placer County, near Lake Tahoe
Sea level up to altitude of 3,000 feet Usually from 5,000 feet up to 8,000 feet altitude
Region of annual rainfall from 20 to 100 inches Region of annual rainfall from 18 to 60 inches
Warm, humid atmosphere Cool, dry atmosphere
Temperature range from 15° F to 100° F Temperature range from zero to 100° F

REPRODUCTION AND GROWTH:
Cones, small, from 5/8-inch to 1-1/8 inches long; mature first season Cones, larger, 1-3/4 to 2-3/4 inches long; mature second season
Cone scales, from 14 to 24 in each cone. Cone scales, from 35 to 40 in each cone
Seeds, from 50 to 60 in each cone. Seeds, from 150 to 250 in each cone
Reproduction by seeds, and by root sprouts Reproduction by seeds only
Young trees moderately tolerant of shade Young trees not tolerant of shade
Growth rapid in long growing season Growth slower in short growing season
Pure stands often found Mixed stands generally found

CULTIVATION:
Extensive use in reforestation Moderate use in reforestation
Extensive planting as ornamental in Hawaii, New Zealand, southern Europe, and warmer parts of North America Extensive planting as ornamental in Europe, Asia, and many parts of North America

BARK, LEAF, AND ROOT CHARACTERS:
Dull red, richly colored bark. Reddish brown, duller bark
Bark shallowly fissured with small ridges Bark deeply furrowed with large ridges
Bark from 1/4-foot to 1 foot thick at base of trunks of large trees Bark from 1/2-foot to 2 feet thick at base of trunks of large trees
Leaves flat, needle-like resembling Hemlock or Fir Leaves small, scale-like, resembling leaves of Juniper or Cypress
Leaves linear, petioled, from 1/8-inch to 1-1/4 inches long, spreading in two flat ranks Leaves awl-shaped, sessile, 1/12 to 1/2-inch long, growing all around the stem
Root spread, from 40 to 50 feet from base of tree, at from 4 to 6 feet below surface of ground Root spread, from 100 to 150 feet from base of tree, at from 6 to 8 feet below surface of ground

COMMERCIAL USES:
Wood tough, heavy, and strong Wood brittle, light, and weaker
Dry weight of wood, 26.2 lbs per cu. ft. Dry weight of wood, 18.2 lbs. per cu. ft.
First commercially lumbered in 1850 First commercially lumbered in 1890
Wood has tendency to split lengthwise when tree is felled Wood has tendency to break crosswise when tree is felled
Waste in lumbering, from 25 to 50 per cent Waste in lumbering, from 45 to 50 per cent
Still lumbered, and produces most of the redwood lumber of commerce Almost no lumbering at the present time

BURLS AND KNOTS:
Burls produced on roots and trunks Knots produced on roots and trunks
Burls cut from tree and placed in moist location will grow new foliage Knots cut from tree will not grow new foliage
Burls valuable for table tops, curios, etc. Knots have no commercial value

SIZE AND AGE:
Average diameter of mature trees, from 12 to 16 feet Average diameter of mature trees, from 28 to 32 feet
Maximum base diameter, 22.8 feet Maximum base diameter, 40.3 feet
Height of many trees, from 300 to 350 feet Height of many trees, from 250 to 300 feet
Height of tallest known tree ("Founders' Tree"), 364 feet Height of tallest known tree ("California"), 310 feet
Maximum total volume of one tree, 361,366 board feet Maximum total volume of one tree, 600,120 board feet
Twenty-two 5-room bungalows could be built from lumber of one tree Forty 5-room bungalows could be built from lumber of one tree
Average age of mature trees, from 800 to 1,500 years Average age of mature trees, from 2,000 to 3,000 years
Maximum reported age, 2,000 years Maximum reported age, 4,000 years

SAVING THE REDWOODS:
Many groves owned by individuals and lumber companies Few groves owned by individuals and lumber companies
One National Monument, several State, County, and City parks preserve stands of Coast Redwood Three National Parks, three National Forests, and one State Park preserve stands of Sierra Redwood

THE FOUNDERS' TREE—THE WORLD'S TALLEST TREE Courtesy of Gabriel Moulin

<<< PREVIOUS CONTENTS NEXT >>>

The Redwoods of Coast and Sierra
©1940, University of California Press
shirley/sec12.htm — 02-Feb-2007